5 Shortening Substitutes for Frosting (All You Need to Know)

Rate this post

In order to make frosting that has a texture that is airy and fluffy, you need to use shortening, which has such features. Despite this, a significant number of individuals now prefer other available options. Perhaps they are interested in a product that has a lower amount of trans fat or they do not have any shortening in their kitchen. If you are creating frosting, you may be curious about the other ingredients that may be used in their place.

While creating your frosting, you may use any of these five ingredients for shortening instead. These items include but are not limited to butter, coconut oil, ghee, margarine, and vegan butter. One thing to keep in mind, however, is that there will be a tiny difference in texture; thus, being familiar with these differences may assist you in adjusting the recipe.

The issue with frosting is that in order to make it fluffy and light, it requires shortening because of its consistency and the other features it has. As a result, if you don’t want to use shortening and you’re looking for alternatives that are healthier, you’ll need to make some modifications to the way the dish is prepared.

You will see in this post our in-depth view on each of these five alternatives to shortening that you may use, as well as how you can adapt them to produce a frosting even without the usage of shortening.

Let’s not waste any more time and get right in, shall we?

Can you use shortening instead of frosting?

In order to get a texture that is airy and fluffy while creating frosting, you will need to use shortening. You may, however, always discover other solutions to use in its place, whether you do not have access to shortening or you would prefer not to use it.

For instance, you probably already have access to a number of fantastic choices inside your own kitchen. Let’s take a look at each one of these alternatives to shortening and see how they may be used.

Frosting compensates for shortening

The following is a list of five other items that may be used in place of shortening in recipes.


If you do not have any shortening on hand or if you do not want to use any, you may substitute a stick of butter for the shortening. One important point to keep in mind is that butter is made up of more than just fat, while shortening is composed entirely of fat.

Because of this, you may modify the recipe by adding a little bit more butter rather than putting in the same quantity of butter each time. In addition, it will be beneficial for the butter to remain at room temperature, or at the very least, to be soft enough without totally melting.

It is possible that the outcome may not be optimal in terms of fluffiness and lightness in texture if you choose this option. On the other hand, you may always have a taste that is rich like butter in your icing.

Cocoa Butter

You may use coconut oil instead of butter if you don’t want to, and this will work out well for you since coconut oil has a consistency that’s quite similar to that of shortening. One further advantage is the fact that it is suitable for vegans.

When you make your frosting using coconut oil as a replacement, one thing to keep in mind is that it will have a faint taste of coconut because of the oil. This nugget of information could be appreciated by some individuals while others might not.

If you fall into the second category, you should opt for refined coconut oil rather than unprocessed versions of the product. You will end up with a taste that is not overpowering like you would with a shortening if you do it this way.

As you are making the frosting, it is important to ensure that the coconut oil does not get entirely molten at any point. It would be best if it were at room temperature since then it won’t be solid, but it also won’t be as fluid as it would be otherwise.


Ghee, which is also known as clarified butter, is yet another excellent option that you are free to make use of. When it comes to preparing frosting, this ingredient is generally considered to be a superior substitute to butter.

The milk solids and water were removed from ghee before it was made into butter, which is what sets it apart from butter. As a consequence of this, a more refined type of fat is produced.

Moreover, it is an excellent substitute for using shortening. Nevertheless, when you use the ghee to create the frosting, you need to be sure that it has not completely melted.

In any recipe that asks for shortening, such as frosting, you may substitute one-to-one for the shortening to give the dish a taste that is reminiscent of butter.

When you make frosting using ghee instead of shortening, you can be certain that it will always have a robust taste that you will undoubtedly appreciate. This is because ghee has a higher butter content than shortening does.


In addition to playing a role in the taste of the final product, margarine is an excellent substitute for shortening.

The sole difference is that margarine has a higher water content and a lower total fat percentage than butter does. As a result, you will need to modify the recipe by include more margarine in order to make up for the absence of shortening.

For instance, you may make up for the absence of one cup of shortening by using one additional cup and tablespoon of margarine in the recipe. You may add more or less margarine to the frosting, and the amount you use will depend on how much frosting you prepare.

Vegan Spread

There is a large selection of vegan butter available in stores nowadays. As a result, it would be beneficial to have the ability to use it in place of shortening in any recipe that asks for the latter.

To get the correct proportion of fat to water, add one or two tablespoons of shortening to each cup of water. This will provide the desired result.

If you want to create frosting but are worried about what could be in the ingredients, vegan butter might be a great replacement for shortening.

But, similar to ghee and butter, you want to make sure that your vegan butter is not totally melted, or at the very least that it is soft and at room temperature. In this manner, the procedure will be controllable, and the outcomes will be very substantially more analogous to shortening.


When it comes to creating frosting, you have the option of using one of five different alternatives to shortening in lieu of the traditional ingredient. You are welcome to make use of butter, ghee, margarine, coconut oil, or vegan butter. Since this modification will result in a discernible shift in texture, it is in your best interest to familiarize yourself with these modifications right away so that you can appropriately adapt your recipe.

When it comes to frosting, the issue about it is that it requires the consistency and other features of shortening in order to make it seem fluffy and light. This is the case because of the way that frosting is made. To put it another way, if you do not want to use shortening and you are looking for alternatives that are healthy, you will have to make some modifications to the way you go about the cooking process.


What can you substitute for shortening in frosting?

Although though butter and margarine may both be used in place of shortening, it is important to take into account the amount of moisture that each of these ingredients has before making the switch. Although shortening is composed entirely of fat, margarine and butter both include a trace amount of water in them (so, shortening adds more fat, thus more richness and tenderness).

What are the 5 types of shortening?

In the food industry, butter, lard, vegetable oils, processed shortenings, and margarine are all considered to be important shortenings.

What is the use of shortening in frosting?

Shortening contributes to the texture and stability of food in the same way as butter contributes to flavor. A light and airy frosting is easier to make with the aid of shortening, which also contributes a flavorless component that helps balance out the butter’s inherent richness.

What is the common substitute for shortening?

The Greatest Alternative to Shortening for Cooking and Frying in Canola Oil

All of the following oils have high smoke points and may be used for frying: vegetable oil, coconut oil, peanut oil, avocado oil, and grapeseed oil. Nevertheless, vegetable oil is your best choice since it is flavorless and economical.

What are the 4 kinds of shortening that usually used in baking?

There are four distinct kinds of shortening, including cake or icing shortening, liquid shortening, all-purpose shortening, and solid shortening. The most common applications for solid include making pie crusts, pastries, and bread. It may be purchased in a can or in a form similar to butter known as “baking sticks.”

What is a healthy substitute for Crisco?

A fantastic alternative to shortening that is derived from plants is coconut oil. It has a solid state at room temperature and behaves similarly to butter and shortening in that it may be melted and whipped into a paste. Be aware that the finished product may have a hint of the taste of coconut since the coconut oil was used.

What are the examples of shortening give at least one of its uses?

Shortening is a kind of fat that is solid at room temperature and may be used to impart a crumbly and crisp texture to dishes such as pastry. Shortening is described as a fat that can be employed. Butter, margarine, lard, and vegetable oils are some kinds of fat that may be used in the “shortening” process.

What are the three kinds of shortening?

The solid form is recommended for use in baked goods such as bread, pies, and pastries.
The majority of the time, liquid shortening is called for in recipes like cake and bread that ask for melted shortening.
All-purpose: Hydrogenated shortening that has not been emulsified.
Further things… Categories

What is natural shortening?

In a technical sense, the word “shortening” may be used to describe to any kind of fat that remains solid even when it is at room temperature. This includes lard, butter, and margarine. Shortening may be prepared using either animal fat or vegetable oil; however, the vast majority of shortening that is sold in stores today is prepared using vegetable oils such as soybean, cottonseed, or palm oil.

What shortening is best for frosting?

Because of this, the texture that is produced by vegetable shortening is one that is light and airy, making it an excellent choice for icing cakes and cupcakes. In addition, it is quite sturdy and hard, making it great for decorating or piping.